diff --git a/YACOSWeb/WebContent/WEB-INF/jsp/listEvaluation.jsp b/YACOSWeb/WebContent/WEB-INF/jsp/listEvaluation.jsp
index 1f416a1..cad2e1e 100644
--- a/YACOSWeb/WebContent/WEB-INF/jsp/listEvaluation.jsp
+++ b/YACOSWeb/WebContent/WEB-INF/jsp/listEvaluation.jsp
@@ -17,28 +17,32 @@
 		<table style="width: 100%">
 			<tr>
 				<td colspan="2" align="center">
-					<a title="Download" href="<c:url value="/download.htm"><c:param name="articleId" value="${article.id}"/></c:url>"><b>${article.title}</b></a> by ${article.mainAuthor.firstName} ${article.mainAuthor.lastName}
+					<a title="Download" href="<c:url value="/download.htm"><c:param name="articleId" value="${article.article.id}"/></c:url>"><b>${article.article.title}</b></a> by ${article.article.mainAuthor.firstName} ${article.article.mainAuthor.lastName}
 				</td>
 			</tr>
 			<tr>
 				<td align="left">
-					Topic: <b>${article.topic}</b><br/>
-					Abstract: ${article.abstractText}
+					Topic: <b>${article.article.topic}</b><br/>
+					Abstract: ${article.article.abstractText}
 				</td>
 				<td align="right">
-					<c:if test="${article.state eq 'SUBMITED'}">
-						<a title="Click to evaluate" href="<c:url value="evaluation.htm?id=${article.id}"/>">Evaluate <img src="./images/button_follow_32x32.png" alt="Click to evaluate" /></a>
+        			<c:if test="${article.evaluated == false}">
+        				<c:if test="${article.article.state != 'REJECTED' and  article.article.state != 'ACCEPTED'}">
+							<a title="Click to evaluate" href="<c:url value="evaluation.htm?id=${article.article.id}"/>">Evaluate <img src="./images/button_follow_32x32.png" alt="Click to evaluate" /></a>
+						</c:if>
         			</c:if>
         
-        			<c:if test="${article.state eq 'EVALUATED'}">
-						<a title="Click to modify evaluation" href="<c:url value="evaluation.htm?id=${article.id}&action=modify"/>">Modify the evaluation <img src="./images/cc-kedit-32x32.png" alt="Click to modify evaluation" /></a>
+        			<c:if test="${article.evaluated == true}">
+        				<c:if test="${article.article.state != 'REJECTED' and  article.article.state != 'ACCEPTED'}">
+							<a title="Click to modify evaluation" href="<c:url value="evaluation.htm?id=${article.article.id}&action=modify"/>">Modify the evaluation <img src="./images/cc-kedit-32x32.png" alt="Click to modify evaluation" /></a>
+						</c:if>
         			</c:if>
         
-        			<c:if test="${article.state eq 'REJECTED'}">
+        			<c:if test="${article.article.state eq 'REJECTED'}">
 						Rejected <img src="./images/cancel32.png" alt="This article has been rejected" />
         			</c:if>
         
-        			<c:if test="${article.state eq 'ACCEPTED'}">
+        			<c:if test="${article.article.state eq 'ACCEPTED'}">
 						Accepted <img src="./images/ok32.png" alt="This article has been accepted" />
         			</c:if>
 				</td>
diff --git a/YACOSWeb/WebContent/WEB-INF/yacos-servlet.xml b/YACOSWeb/WebContent/WEB-INF/yacos-servlet.xml
index 144c64e..c2bd381 100644
--- a/YACOSWeb/WebContent/WEB-INF/yacos-servlet.xml
+++ b/YACOSWeb/WebContent/WEB-INF/yacos-servlet.xml
@@ -280,6 +280,7 @@
 		class="org.yacos.web.PCmember.controller.ListEvaluationController">
 		<property name="articleManager" ref="articleManager" />
 		<property name="userManager" ref="userManager" />
+		<property name="evaluationManager" ref="evaluationManager" />
    </bean>
    
     <bean id="StateArticleController"
diff --git a/YACOSWeb/src/org/yacos/web/PCmember/controller/ListEvaluationController.java b/YACOSWeb/src/org/yacos/web/PCmember/controller/ListEvaluationController.java
index 4f816c4..46d4d0f 100644
--- a/YACOSWeb/src/org/yacos/web/PCmember/controller/ListEvaluationController.java
+++ b/YACOSWeb/src/org/yacos/web/PCmember/controller/ListEvaluationController.java
@@ -15,8 +15,11 @@ import org.springframework.web.servlet.mvc.SimpleFormController;
 import org.yacos.core.article.Article;
 import org.yacos.core.article.IArticleManager;
 import org.yacos.core.conferences.Conference;
+import org.yacos.core.evaluation.IEvaluationManager;
+import org.yacos.core.evaluation.Report;
 import org.yacos.core.users.IUserManager;
 import org.yacos.core.users.Role.RoleType;
+import org.yacos.web.PCmember.form.EvaluationArticleBean;
 import org.yacos.web.system.controller.NoConferenceSelectedException;
 import org.yacos.web.system.session.SessionService;
 
@@ -26,6 +29,16 @@ public class ListEvaluationController extends SimpleFormController {
 
 	private IArticleManager articleManager;
 	private IUserManager userManager;
+	private IEvaluationManager evaluationManager;
+
+
+	public IEvaluationManager getEvaluationManager() {
+		return evaluationManager;
+	}
+
+	public void setEvaluationManager(IEvaluationManager evaluationManager) {
+		this.evaluationManager = evaluationManager;
+	}
 
 	public IArticleManager getArticleManager() {
 		return articleManager;
@@ -53,14 +66,29 @@ public class ListEvaluationController extends SimpleFormController {
 			return new ModelAndView("main","end","evaluation");
 		}		
 		List<Article> listArticle = new ArrayList<Article>();
-		
+		List<EvaluationArticleBean> listArticleBean = new ArrayList<EvaluationArticleBean>();
+
 		String person = request.getParameter("role");
-		
+
 		// TODO : renvoyer un truc s'il n'a pas le role
-		
+
 		if (person.equals("pcmember")) {
 			if (userManager.hasRoleForConference(SessionService.getInstance().getCurrentUserLogin(), RoleType.PCMEMBER, conf.getId())) {
 				listArticle = articleManager.getArticlesOfMember(conf.getId(), SessionService.getInstance().getCurrentUserLogin());
+				for (Article a: listArticle) {
+					EvaluationArticleBean eab = new EvaluationArticleBean();
+					eab.setArticle(a);
+
+					Report rpt = evaluationManager.getReportforArticleAndReferee(a.getId(), SessionService.getInstance().getCurrentUserLogin());
+					if (rpt == null) {
+						eab.setEvaluated(false);
+					}
+					else {
+						eab.setEvaluated(true);
+					}
+					listArticleBean.add(eab);
+
+				}
 			}
 		}
 		else if (person.equals("referee")) {
@@ -70,9 +98,23 @@ public class ListEvaluationController extends SimpleFormController {
 				if (listArticleTmp != null) {
 					for (Article a : listArticleTmp) {
 						Conference confTmp = articleManager.getConferenceForArticle(a.getId());
-						if (confTmp.getId() == conf.getId())
+						if (confTmp.getId().equals(conf.getId()))
 							listArticle.add(a);
 					}
+					for (Article a: listArticle) {
+						EvaluationArticleBean eab = new EvaluationArticleBean();
+						eab.setArticle(a);
+
+						Report rpt = evaluationManager.getReportforArticleAndReferee(a.getId(), SessionService.getInstance().getCurrentUserLogin());
+						if (rpt == null) {
+							eab.setEvaluated(false);
+						}
+						else {
+							eab.setEvaluated(true);
+						}
+						listArticleBean.add(eab);
+
+					}
 				}
 			}
 		}
@@ -80,6 +122,6 @@ public class ListEvaluationController extends SimpleFormController {
 			throw new ModelAndViewDefiningException(new ModelAndView("404error"));
 
 
-		return new ModelAndView("listEvaluation", "listArticle", listArticle);
+		return new ModelAndView("listEvaluation", "listArticle", listArticleBean);
 	}
 }
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/YACOSWeb/src/org/yacos/web/PCmember/form/EvaluationArticleBean.java b/YACOSWeb/src/org/yacos/web/PCmember/form/EvaluationArticleBean.java
new file mode 100644
index 0000000..b167b8c
--- /dev/null
+++ b/YACOSWeb/src/org/yacos/web/PCmember/form/EvaluationArticleBean.java
@@ -0,0 +1,23 @@
+package org.yacos.web.PCmember.form;
+
+import org.yacos.core.article.Article;
+
+public class EvaluationArticleBean {
+	
+  private Article article;
+  private boolean evaluated;
+  
+public Article getArticle() {
+	return article;
+}
+public void setArticle(Article article) {
+	this.article = article;
+}
+public boolean isEvaluated() {
+	return evaluated;
+}
+public void setEvaluated(boolean evaluated) {
+	this.evaluated = evaluated;
+}
+
+}